cloudyu commited on
Commit
f178779
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 3ea6d7a

Model card: agent judge (AgentRewardBench)

Browse files
Files changed (2) hide show
  1. README.md +24 -0
  2. agent_judge.png +0 -0
README.md CHANGED
@@ -66,6 +66,29 @@ about 300 ms per decision (4× playback).
66
 
67
  <video src="https://huggingface.co/autotrust/JEV-27B-VL/resolve/main/videos/vl5.mp4" controls autoplay loop muted playsinline width="100%"></video>
68
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
69
  ## Highlight: multimodal judge
70
 
71
  Given an image, a question and two answers, System 1 says which answer is better, zero-shot and in one forward pass per order.
@@ -175,6 +198,7 @@ Human gold labels (CLINC-150, MTOP, GoEmotions, DBpedia), 800 items.
175
  | task | result | comparison |
176
  |---|---|---|
177
  | **Image recommendation, zero-shot** (MicroLens, covers only) · JEV-27B-VL | **AUC 0.727** | collaborative filtering from 59,045 users' logs 0.728 · titles only 0.649 |
 
178
  | **Multimodal judge** (VL-RewardBench, 1,247 pairs) · JEV-27B-VL | **78.3% accuracy**, above every model on its 2025 leaderboard | Skywork-VL-Reward-7B 73.3 · GPT-4o 65.8 · Claude 3.5 Sonnet 55.3 |
179
  | **Multimodal judge** (MMRB2, 4 × 1,000 pairs) · JEV-27B-VL | text-to-image **69.2**, average **63.8** | GPT-5 70.5 / 72.2 · GPT-4.1 65.8 / 63.5 · GPT-4o 60.3 / 59.7 |
180
  | **Biomedical research questions** (PubMedQA test, 500) · JEV-27B-VL | **77.8% accuracy**, zero-shot | human experts 78.0% · GPT-4 zero-shot 75.2% · BioBERT 68.1% |
 
66
 
67
  <video src="https://huggingface.co/autotrust/JEV-27B-VL/resolve/main/videos/vl5.mp4" controls autoplay loop muted playsinline width="100%"></video>
68
 
69
+ ## Highlight: agent judge (AgentRewardBench)
70
+
71
+ Did the web agent really finish the task? Given the user's goal, the agent's actions and final message, and the final
72
+ screenshot, System 1 returns P(task completed) in one forward pass, zero-shot. On
73
+ [AgentRewardBench](https://agent-reward-bench.github.io) (McGill, 2025; 1,302 expert-labelled trajectories from GPT-4o, Claude
74
+ 3.7, Llama 3.3 and Qwen2.5-VL agents) its precision is **higher than every judge on the official leaderboard at that judge's own
75
+ recall**:
76
+
77
+ | judge | its precision | its recall | **JEV-27B-VL at the same recall** |
78
+ |---|---:|---:|---:|
79
+ | Rule-based | 83.8 | 55.9 | **86.2** |
80
+ | WebJudge (o4-mini) | 82.0 | 47.8 | **87.7** |
81
+ | WebJudge-7B (trained judge) | 75.7 | 58.0 | **86.2** |
82
+ | World-State-Model-7B (trained judge) | 71.2 | 72.2 | **77.7** |
83
+ | GPT-4o (accessibility tree) | 69.8 | 83.1 | **72.9** |
84
+ | Claude 3.7 Sonnet (screenshot) | 69.4 | 76.3 | **75.6** |
85
+ | Qwen2.5-VL-72B (screenshot) | 64.5 | 86.1 | **67.9** |
86
+
87
+ At threshold 0.5: precision 78.4, recall 70.2; AUROC 0.91. All 1,302 judgements in about 4 minutes on one GPU. Code:
88
+ [JEV-27B-DEMO / 10-agent-judge](https://github.com/yuhai-china/JEV-27B-DEMO/tree/master/10-agent-judge).
89
+
90
+ ![agent judge](agent_judge.png)
91
+
92
  ## Highlight: multimodal judge
93
 
94
  Given an image, a question and two answers, System 1 says which answer is better, zero-shot and in one forward pass per order.
 
198
  | task | result | comparison |
199
  |---|---|---|
200
  | **Image recommendation, zero-shot** (MicroLens, covers only) · JEV-27B-VL | **AUC 0.727** | collaborative filtering from 59,045 users' logs 0.728 · titles only 0.649 |
201
+ | **Agent judge** (AgentRewardBench, 1,302 trajectories) · JEV-27B-VL | **higher precision than all 16 leaderboard judges** at their recall; AUROC 0.91 | o4-mini, GPT-4o, Claude 3.7, trained 7B judges |
202
  | **Multimodal judge** (VL-RewardBench, 1,247 pairs) · JEV-27B-VL | **78.3% accuracy**, above every model on its 2025 leaderboard | Skywork-VL-Reward-7B 73.3 · GPT-4o 65.8 · Claude 3.5 Sonnet 55.3 |
203
  | **Multimodal judge** (MMRB2, 4 × 1,000 pairs) · JEV-27B-VL | text-to-image **69.2**, average **63.8** | GPT-5 70.5 / 72.2 · GPT-4.1 65.8 / 63.5 · GPT-4o 60.3 / 59.7 |
204
  | **Biomedical research questions** (PubMedQA test, 500) · JEV-27B-VL | **77.8% accuracy**, zero-shot | human experts 78.0% · GPT-4 zero-shot 75.2% · BioBERT 68.1% |
agent_judge.png ADDED